By the turn of the century, two industries were on a clear collision course: the promotional products industry and the premium industry. Promotional products won. The real question is: what exactly did they win?
Many newcomers to our industry may not know how these two channels operated from the 1960s through roughly 2000.
Thousands of suppliers serving the promotional products industry brought products to market almost exclusively through jobbers, also known as distributors. These were not the traditional distributors who bought inventory, warehoused it, and took resale risk. Our industry's version was quite different. The distributor acted as an intermediary, generating sales without having to purchase and stock merchandise. It was, and still is, an attractive business model with relatively limited risk and significant reward. The margins have historically been strong enough to support major industry players and large online platforms alike.
The premium industry operated differently.
Consumer brands, the household names everyone recognized, often possessed what I call "brand ego." If you wanted a well-known brand for your promotion, you had to buy directly from that brand, usually at premium prices. To reach the market, these companies generally bypassed distributors and instead worked through independent sales representatives and rep organizations. Those reps solicited programs and earned commissions, typically ranging from 5% to 15%, paid directly by the brand.
I remember sitting in the "cookie office" with a distributor many years ago. Also waiting in the reception area was a premium representative I knew quite well. We were both there to see executives from major cookie brands. The distributor was meeting with the Oreo marketing manager, while the rep was waiting to see the Chips Ahoy product manager. Both were pursuing gift-with-purchase programs. At the time, there was very little crossover between the traditional promotional products marketplace and the world of consumer-brand premiums.
Over time, however, the premium industry was largely absorbed into the promotional products industry. Today's distributors often wear multiple hats. They sell large volumes of merchandise with no consumer brand attached, yet when the opportunity requires it, they can also bring recognized retail brands into the mix using a completely different sales model.
The Present Day
Recently, I visited CVS to receive my flu and COVID shots. While waiting, I browsed the aisles and found myself asking: Where did all the premiums go?
Not that many years ago, consumer brands regularly used premiums to promote their products. Yet during my visit, I could not find a single premium promotion anywhere in the store.
Twenty-five years ago, I worked on a promotion for CVS that was funded by a children's cough medicine manufacturer. The company ordered 50,000 CDs filled with children's sing-along songs and activities. The CDs were offered as a gift with purchase and displayed as a near-pack promotion. It was a classic example of premium marketing.
This time, I saw nothing similar. No gift-with-purchase offers on shelves, no in-pack surprises, no near-pack incentives. Considering that CVS functions in many ways like a mini-supermarket, the absence was striking. Supermarkets traditionally relied heavily on premiums to differentiate one brand from another.
After CVS, I walked through Publix.
I started in the cereal aisle and examined every cereal box I could find. Once again, I discovered no premiums, no incentives, and no gifts with purchase, at least not in the traditional sense. There were plenty of activities on sugary cereal boxes and lots of educational content on healthier brands. But there were no toys inside, no giveaways attached to the package, and no promotional offers sitting beside the product.
What I did see everywhere were QR codes.
The QR code has become the new portal to the premium world.
Today, you see QR codes on packaging, apparel, promotional products, and retail merchandise. Generating a QR code takes only seconds. The real question is what lies at the other end of that code.
That is where the opportunity resides.
The industry may have moved away from physical premiums because fulfillment, shipping, and handling costs have become increasingly difficult to justify. But technology offers a path forward. The most successful marketing agencies of the future may build digital repositories, content libraries, experiences, rewards, and benefits that can be delivered instantly through a scan.
Imagine a system where a consumer scans a code and automatically receives a relevant premium, digital content, discount, reward, membership benefit, or personalized experience. No warehouse. No shipping carton. No human intervention. Just immediate value delivered through technology.
The Untapped Opportunity
I have been involved with premiums for more than 50 years and promotional products for nearly 60. I have watched the industry adapt to the internet, e-commerce, and a changing economy that has made many traditional premium programs cost-prohibitive.
Yet I believe there is still a pot of gold waiting to be discovered.
A seamless, hands-off premium delivery system could unlock an enormous amount of marketing spending if it delivers genuine consumer value. The tools now exist. What remains is the creativity to use them effectively.
I realize this may not be in the wheelhouse of the average distributor. Then again, it doesn't have to be. Those willing to actively pursue this type of business can partner with software developers, digital marketers, content creators, app designers, AI specialists, and entrepreneurs who are already generating innovative ideas.
The talent is out there.
Network beyond your traditional comfort zone. Collaborate with people who think differently. You may discover that your comfort zone becomes a lot larger, and far more profitable, than you ever imagined.
Joel D. Schaffer, MAS is CEO and Founder of Soundline, LLC, the pioneering supplier to the promotional products industry of audio products. Joel has 48 years of promotional product industry experience and proudly heralds “I was a distributor.” He has been on the advisory panel of the business and marketing department of St. John’s University in New York and is a frequent speaker at Rutgers Graduate School of Business. He is an industry Advocate and has appeared before the American Bankers Association, American Marketing Association, National Premium Sales Executives, American Booksellers Association and several other major groups. He has been a management consultant to organizations such as The College Board and helped many suppliers enter this industry. He is a frequent contributor to PPB and Counselor magazines. He has facilitated over 200 classes sharing his industry knowledge nationwide. He is known for his cutting humor and enthusiasm in presenting provocative and motivating programs. He is the only person to have received both the Marvin Spike Industry Lifetime Achievement Award (2002) and PPAI’s Distinguished Service Award (2011). He is a past director of PPAI and has chaired several PPAI committees and task forces. He is a past Chair of the SAAGNY Foundation, Past President of SAAGNY and a SAAGNY Hall of Fame member. He was cited by ASI as one of the 50 most influential people in the industry.